| Born
on:
September 5, 1999 |
WELCOME TO MODULE 8: THEME ANALYSIS
Title of this web page -->Narrative Methods for Organizational and Communication Research
by David M. Boje, Ph.D.
Purpose: a web resource library of qualitative materials, exercises, and study guides to supplement the (2001) book titled Narrative Methods for Organizational and Communication Research. London: Sage Publications. See Amazon to order book and/or read book review.Each module on this web site will tackle a different analysis in Narrative Analysis for Management and Communication Research (hereafter NA). Then we situate that analysis in its philosophy of science context - (press here) for summary table.
Readings Index & Abbreviations Explained (All Modules)
Background Reading for this Module (bold = required).
- NA Narrative Analysis for Management and Communication Research (book) by Boje (2001) the modules that follow are keyed to the chapters of this book.
- HQR: Handbook of Qualitative Research by Denzin & Lincoln (can buy the soft cover books; excellent book for background on methods and qualitative philosophies of science).
- ES: Ethnostatistics by Gephart (this book transcends all false dichotomies of qualitative and quantitative).
- WC: Writing Culture by Clifford & Marcus (optional good for intermediate).
- PO: Participant Observation by Spradley (optional good for beginners).
- GC: Greening Culture by Herndl & Brown (optional great for very advanced QM writing).
- FG: Focus Group text by Krueger (required for Marketing, optional for others).
- NA - Chapter 8 - Theme Analysis
MODULE 8 - THEME ANALYSIS - (Continued) - there is a floating menu on your left that takes you between modules or to the top of this one.
Content analysis & semiotic inquiry: Recording, organizing data and identifying domains and taxonomies
ASSIGNMENT READ and Note Each of 5 Frames:
- Figure Interactive 5 Frame study guide
- 1. What is Bureaucratic Frame?
- 2. What is Quest Frame?
- 3. What is Chaos Frame?
- 4. What is Postmodern Frame?
- 5. What is Antenarrative?
- Background paper on Narrative Frames
- Now that you are prepared take the 5 Narrative Frames Survey and I will email you back your answers (you can also just print it out when done).
Boje presentation in Netherlands: Flight of Antenarrative in Phenomenal Complexity Theory, Tamara, Storytelling Organization Theory
Boje presentation in Netherlands: Before the Story Can be Told: An Antenarrative of the World Trade Center and Pentagon Disaster; also see Hybridity Visuals
ASSIGNMENT OPTIONS
A. Theme Analysis Assignment: Based upon the descriptions provided in Nike activist documents on the web at http://business.nmsu.edu/~dboje/nike.html, conduct and share your own domain, taxonomy, and componential analyses (Spradley, step 5, step 7, & step 11). Write up your taxonomy, componential, and domain charts listing definitions of your categories and report your classification schemes in this class meeting.B. Assignment: Conduct a focus group of a College at NMSU. Using a tape recorder and your notebook, take a cultural inventory (Spradley step 11) of our organizational history by asking two to three folks to discuss their organizational life and the significant things that have happened to them. Don't worry about getting the events in the right chronological order. But, do follow up with domain and cultural inventory questions. It is often better to let them tell their stories in the order of importance to them, and then to relate other events as they come to memory in the telling. Then, follow-up with domain and theme analysis. It is usually a very bad idea to work with someone who you know well, such as a family member or good friend. Include in your notes at least one page of close transcription of the tape. Enter your data and codes and schema into the NUDIST program. Bring your printouts to class.
C. Do some variation of a theme analysis using your own semester term project.
Readings
NA - Theme Analysis
Guy Delord & Gil Wolman, "Methods of Détournement," Les Levres Nues, #8, May 1956. http://www.nothingness.org/SI/journaleng/detournement.html
HANDOUT: Prasad. 1993 AMJ. Symbolic processes in the implementation of technological change: A symbolic interactionist study of work computerization.
HQR: Tuchman. Historical social science: Methodologies, methods, and meanings. Pp. 306-323.
PO: Step 11 Taking a cultural inventory. Pp. 155-159.
*PO: Step 5: Making a domain analysis. Pp. 85-99.
*PO: Step 7: Making a taxonomic analysis. Pp. 112-121.
*PO: Step 11: Making a componential analysis. Pp. 130-139.
*PO: Step 10: Discovering cultural themes. Pp. 140-154.
FG: Chapter 1 & 2, and appendix.
GC. Bergman. "The curious peach:" Nature and the language of desire. Pp. 281-303.
GC. Ulman. Thinking like a mountain: Personal, ethos, and judgment in American nature writing. Pp. 46-82.
FG: Chapter 7. PO: The ethnographic research cycle. Pp. 26-35.
HANDOUT: Boje, Luhman & Baack, "Choral Company."
Semiotics Review http://www.cudenver.edu/~mryder/itc_data/semiotics.html
Semiotics special interest group [search] http://www.soc.staffs.ac.uk/~cmtkl/ssig.html
OM qualitative course description & readings http://cis.gsu.edu/~mberanek/cis928/
EJROT, a scholarly journal at http://www.mngt.waikato.ac.nz/depts/sm&l/journal/ejrot.htm, co-edited by Professor Clive Gilson and Dr Maria Humphries at the University of Waikato, New Zealand (ISSN 1173-6631). Boje is on editorial board.
Semiotics in OM http://comu2.auckland.ac.nz/%7Eisworld/qual/interp.htm
*Daniel Chandler - Content analysis (press here). Good links to examples and articles from marketing and media studies work.
Content Analysis - for quantitative analysis of texts (press here).
On Line Content Analysis Help line (press here).
Article - The Proclamation of Restoration of the Independent Nation of Hawai’i: A Fantasy Theme Analysis By Darin J. Arsenault, May 1997 (press here).
Reading list on this topic (press here).
Brave New World Theme Analysis Example (press here).
Taxonomy
What is taxonomy (press here).
Understanding Taxonomy (press here).
Software (press here).
On line Bio taxonomy map examples (press here).
Formism
Stephen Pepper's World Hypothesis work - The Journal of Mind and Behavior Volume 3, Number 4, Autumn 1982, Special Issue Part 2 (press here).
Stephen Pepper List (press here).
Recommended
Marin, Louis. 1987. Notes on a semiotic approach to parade, cortege, and procession. In Time out of time, ed. Alessandro Falassi, 220-8. Albuquerque: University of New Mexico Press.
Marketing Readings on Content Analysis
Kolbe, Richard and Melissa A. Burnett (1991) Journal of Consumer Research, 18 (Sept.), 243-250
Kassarjian, Harold H. (1977), Journal of Consumer Research, 4 (June),
Krippendorf, Klaus (1980), Content Analysis: An Introduction to Its Methodology, Beverly Hills: Sage
Berelson, Bernard (1952), Content Analysis in Communications Research, Glencoe, IL: Free Press
Wheeler, David R. (1988), International Marketing Review, (Winter)
MODULE - begin again module introduction
or (use menu to your left)